Click here to


Are you sure ?

Yes, do it No, cancel

Comparison Between TrueBeam Millennium And High Definition MLC With Halcyon Dual-Layer MLC: Impact of Collimator Leaf Width On Plan Quality for Stereotactic Body Radiotherapy for Spine Tumors

H Petroccia*, L Dong , I Malajovich , B Teo , T Li , University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA


(Wednesday, 8/1/2018) 9:30 AM - 10:00 AM

Room: Exhibit Hall | Forum 3

Purpose: Spine stereotactic body radiotherapy (SBRT) require treatment plans with steep dose gradients and tight limit to cord maximal dose. A new dual-layer staggered 1-cm MLC in Halcyon treatment platform has improved leakage, speed, and DLG, compared to Millennium (0.5cm) and High Definition (0.25cm) MLC leaves in the TrueBeam platform. In this study, we investigate the effect of different MLC designs on plan quality of spine SBRT treatments.

Methods: 5 patients previously treated with spine SBRT were replanned according to the NRG-BR-001 guidelines for all three MLC systems with a prescription of 3000cGy in 3 fractions, 6xFFF beam, 800cGy/MU dose rate, and 3-arc VMAT technique. All plans were normalized to 95% of the target volume covered by prescription dose. For each case, planning objectives were adjusted manually by experienced planners to generate optimal plans for each platform and kept the same for different MLCs within the TrueBeam platform

Results: All treatment plans were able to achieve adequate target coverage while meeting dosimetric constraints to the OARs set by NRG-BR001 guidelines. Plans optimized for the 0.25cm TrueBeam MLC showed the sharpest dose fall-off, as demonstrated by the smallest conformity index (CI ) at 1.06±0.03 and lowest homogeneity index (HI) at 0.21±0.04, compared to CI 1.10±0.04 and HI 0.25±0.06 for 0.25cm TrueBeam MLC, and CI 1.13±0.04 and HI 0.26±0.06 for Halcyon. Halcyon plans had higher global Dmax (119.1% ±3.4%): on average 3.4% higher than 0.25cm-MLC TrueBeam plans, but similar to 0.5cm-MLC TrueBeam plans.

Conclusion: Even with the 1-cm MLC leaf width, the Halcyon MLC is capable of generating clinically acceptable spine SBRT plans, but inferior in terms of dose fall-off and conformity. Our study indicates MLC width leaf does impact maximum dose to OARs and plan quality; however, it is not a limitation in achieving acceptable plan quality for spine SBRT treatments.


MLC, Treatment Planning, Stereotactic Radiosurgery


TH- External beam- photons: treatment planning/virtual clinical studies

Contact Email